Menu of Squires Dairy Delight in Elkton, Maryland, USA

Menu Overview

Squires Dairy Delight, nestled on 705 E Pulaski Hwy in Elkton, MD, is a remarkable ice cream shop that effortlessly marries nostalgia with quality. This family-owned gem offers an inviting menu that turns classic indulgences into memorable treats. The crown jewel here is their hot fudge — rich, velvety, and deeply comforting, it transports you back to the old-time ice cream parlors, evoking warm childhood memories with every luscious drizzle.

The specialty sundaes are true standouts, each thoughtfully crafted to balance textures and flavors. The Monkey Madness Sundae combines creamy vanilla ice cream, fresh banana slices, chocolate syrup, and a sprinkle of coconut, creating a harmonious blend of fruity sweetness and chocolate richness. For coffee lovers, the Oreo Latte Blast Sundae is a revelation — coffee ice cream layered with brownie chunks, hot fudge, Oreo crumbles, and a dash of cinnamon sparkle delight on the palate. The Cookie Dough Sundae is a nostalgic treat, packed with cookie dough pieces and chocolate chips that add delightful surprises in every bite.

Caramel fans will find joy in the Payday Sundae, where vanilla ice cream meets smooth caramel, crunchy peanuts, and the signature small Payday candy bar, all harmonizing into a salty-sweet sensation. The Coffee Toffee Sundae further showcases Squires’ commitment to complex flavors, marrying robust coffee ice cream with crunchy toffee bits for a satisfying crunch amid creamy sweetness.

What truly enchants visitors, as echoed in many reviews, is not only the diverse variety—from the beloved soft-serve options like the vivid blue goo and rainbow swirl to rich sherbets for the lactose-intolerant—but also the authentic, warm service. The owners’ pride and dedication shine through in every sundae and cone they serve, creating an atmosphere that feels like an extension of one’s own family traditions.

With prices that are as welcoming as the smiles behind the window, Squires Dairy Delight delivers excellent value without compromising quality. It's no wonder locals like Jamie Ruske and Jacklyn Carey rave about their first and multiple visits alike, citing memorable flavors and a genuine community feel. This shop’s charm lies not only in its ice cream but in its ability to reconnect people with simple pleasures and shared moments.

If you find yourself craving comfort, creativity, and a little magic in every scoop, Squires Dairy Delight is a must-visit. Whether it’s their signature hot fudge, specialty sundaes that burst with character, or their thick, kid-friendly soft serve, you’ll discover why this Elkton treasure has stood the test of time and continues to be a beloved stop along Route 40.